126 Nagle Avenue, Manhattan
Apartment building · 87 units · built c. 1913 · Block 2174, Lot 77.
Building permits
- Alteration, filed May 22, 2025, estimated cost $27K, described as “Remove existing 5,000-gallon fuel oil storage tank and install two (2) replacement 330-gallon fuel oil storage tanks. No change in use, egress or occupancy.”
- Alteration, filed Mar 28, 2022, estimated cost $13K, described as “Repair damaged terra cotta above the 5th floor windows on window line #1-2, 5-6, 7-8, 11-12, 13, 20, 21-22. And repoint mortar joints where indicated on the plan.”
- Alteration, filed Mar 22, 2022, described as “Installation of temporary sidewalk shed per plan submitted. Work shall comply with 2014 building codes chapter 33. No change in use, egress and/or occupancy with this application.”
- Alteration, filed Feb 4, 2022, estimated cost $11K, described as “Plumbing working work for the interior renovation of apt 504. Plumbing work to be performed at the existing bathroom and new kitchenette”
- Alteration, filed Jan 13, 2022, estimated cost $30K, described as “Interior renovation to apartment # 504 on 5TH floor and the construction of a new porter's storage closet off the public hallway. Work includes new partitions and interior finishes as per plan. No change in egress, use or occupancy under…”
- Alteration, filed Jun 29, 2020, estimated cost $14K, described as “File for plumbing component of interior apartment renovation at #506 & #507. Replace sink , install new dishwasher and replace gas range at kitchen. Install new shower, lav, and relocate wc at bathroom #1. Replace wc,lav, and tub at…”
- Alteration, filed Mar 3, 2020, estimated cost $5K, described as “Install new kitchen exhaust system , s/s hood and ductwork for commercial space. No change in use, ergress or occupancy.”
Property taxes
- Assessment
- $4,473,900
- 2026–27 tax
- $377,714
- Market value (city estimate)
- $9,942,000
- Taxable value
- $3,068,641
- Assessed land
- $331,650
- Assessed improvements
- $4,142,250
Tax breaks
- J-51 exemption, through Jun 30, 2050, about $185,883 a year below the full tax.
- J-51 abatement, through Dec 31, 2035, a $3,994 credit this tax year.
Zoning
R7-2: floor area ratio 4.48 built, above the 3.44 base zoning allows, which bonuses, transfers or older rules can permit.
Flood zone
Current FEMA flood map: zone X, minimal flood hazard.
Recent sales
- Dec 2, 2025: $16,900,000
Open-market sales since 2016, from the Department of Finance’s sales files.