186 Maine Avenue, Staten Island
Two-family · built c. 1915 · Block 376, Lot 91.
Building permits
- New Building — Residential, filed Dec 16, 2025, 1 unit, 3 stories, described as “Proposed three story detached one-family residence with accessory built-in one car garage.”
- Demolition, filed Sep 25, 2026, estimated cost $30K, described as “Demolition of house and in ground pool”
- Demolition, filed Sep 25, 2026, estimated cost $8K, described as “Demolition of one story structure”
- Alteration, filed Sep 24, 2026, estimated cost $5K, described as “Proposed temporary construction fence for the demolition of the existing residence and construction of three new detached one-family residences located at 182, 188 and 190 maine avenue.”
Property taxes
- Assessment
- $67,800
- 2026–27 tax
- $9,958
- Market value (city estimate)
- $1,130,000
- Taxable value
- $49,374
- Assessed land
- $26,160
- Assessed improvements
- $41,640
Zoning
R2: floor area ratio 0.35 built, 0.75 allowed by base zoning.
Flood zone
Current FEMA flood map: zone X, minimal flood hazard.
Recent sales
- Jan 9, 2026: $1,275,000, 3,360 sq ft ($379 per sq ft)
Open-market sales since 2016, from the Department of Finance’s sales files.