364 Bay Street, Staten Island
Commercial · built 2008 · Block 503, Lot 1.
Building permits
- Alteration, filed Feb 17, 2026, estimated cost $23K, described as “Application filed for sprinkler work as per plans.”
- Alteration, filed Feb 9, 2026, estimated cost $50K, described as “Application filed for mechanical and duct work as per plans.”
- Alteration, filed Sep 29, 2025, estimated cost $60K, described as “Interior alteration to non-bearing partitions onfirst floor. No change in use, occupancy, bulk or egress”
- Alteration, filed Jul 11, 2025, estimated cost $2K, described as “Illuminated non-advertising accessory wall sign - in property lines - domino's. No change of use, egress or occupancy.”
- Alteration, filed Nov 4, 2022, estimated cost $63K, described as “Interior alteration to existing tenant space. Removal of existing plumbing fixtures and installation of new plumbing fixtures. Relocate minor sprinkler heads as required.”
- Alteration, filed Nov 4, 2022, estimated cost $80K, described as “Interior alteration to existing first floor tenant space. Removal of interior partitons, finishes throughout. Installation of new walls, ceiling, fixtures, equipment, finishes and a type 2 hood to accomidate for dominos.”
- Alteration, filed May 24, 2022, described as “Application filed for early permanent foundation element, for proposed residential development filed under application S00718381-I1. Early foundation elements to be integrated into full/final building foundation and structure.”
- Major Renovation — Enlargement, filed Apr 15, 2022, estimated cost $6.6M, 201 units added, 7 stories, described as “Filing an alt-co-NB as an enlargement to an existing 2-story & cellar commercial buildingto a 7-story & cellar mixed-use building w/ 185 apartments”
- Alteration, filed Aug 5, 2021, estimated cost $5K, described as “Install mechanical ductwork along with a/c unit as shown on drawings.”
- Alteration, filed Feb 19, 2020, estimated cost $30K, described as “Plumbing and sprinkler work as per plans.”
- Alteration, filed Jan 29, 2020, estimated cost $20K, described as “Amendment herewith filed to revise scope and plans in accordance with plumbing inspection unit comments”
- Alteration, filed Dec 18, 2019, estimated cost $15K, described as “Installation of steel stairs from 1st floor to 2nd floor as per plans.”
- Alteration, filed Jun 25, 2019, estimated cost $4K, described as “Illuminated non advertising accessory wall sign - inside property line - armed forces career center. No change of use, egress or occupancy.”
Property taxes
- Assessment
- $2,547,000
- 2026–27 tax
- $223,984
- Market value (city estimate)
- $5,660,000
- Taxable value
- $2,064,746
- Assessed land
- $721,350
- Assessed improvements
- $1,825,650
Tax breaks
- ICAP/ICIP exemption, through Jun 30, 2027, about $46,232 a year below the full tax.
Zoning
R6 (part of the lot is R6B): floor area ratio 1.23 built, 2.43 allowed by base zoning.
Flood zone
Current FEMA flood map: zone X, minimal flood hazard.
Recent sales
- Nov 7, 2023: $6,750,000
Open-market sales since 2016, from the Department of Finance’s sales files.
Board and land use applications
- Variance or special permit (Board of Standards and Appeals 232-13-BZ): Variance or special permit, Granted, filed Aug 9, 2013, decided Dec 10, 2013. Special Permit (§73-36) to allow a physical culture establishment (Crunch Fitness) within portions of proposed commercial building. M1-1 zoning district.
- Bay Street Corridor (City Planning P2016R0149): Completed, decided Jul 16, 2019. A series of land use actions, including Zoning Map and Zoning Text Amendments, disposition of city-owned property, and UDAAP approval, to facilitate the Bay Street Corridor Neighborhood Plan. The Plan is intended to connect the existing…
In the news
Permits Filed for 364 Bay Street in Tompkinsville, Staten Island, New York YIMBY, Apr 20, 2022.