1239 Forest Hill Road, Staten Island
Apartment building · 28 units · built 2025 · Block 1965, Lot 49.
Building permits
- New Building — Residential, filed Jul 17, 2024, 1 unit, 2 stories, described as “New 2-story and cellar 1-family townhouse residence”
- New Building — Residential, filed Jul 17, 2024, 1 unit, 2 stories, described as “New 2-story and cellar 1-family townhouse residence”
- New Building — Residential, filed Jul 17, 2024, 1 unit, 2 stories, described as “New 2-story and cellar 1-family townhouse residence”
- New Building — Residential, filed Jul 17, 2024, 1 unit, 2 stories, described as “New 2-story and cellar 1-family townhouse residence”
- Alteration, filed Apr 21, 2026, estimated cost $22K, described as “Installation of Solar PV system on existing rooftop with no change to egress, use or occupancy”
- Demolition, filed Jun 11, 2024, estimated cost $18K, described as “Proposed full demolition of a 1-1/2 story frame house”
- Demolition, filed Jul 10, 2023, estimated cost $16K, described as “Full hand demolition of a detached two-story frame residence”
- Alteration, filed Oct 17, 2022, estimated cost $55K, described as “Construction fence”
- Alteration, filed Feb 9, 2022, estimated cost $3K, described as “Proposed 18 foot curb cut including 2 (18") splays”
- Alteration, filed Jan 25, 2022, estimated cost $16K, described as “Support of excavation for construction of new 2-story residential building”
- Alteration, filed Jan 12, 2022, estimated cost $24K, described as “Erect new 2-story residential building”
- Alteration, filed Jan 12, 2022, estimated cost $10K, described as “Foundation for new 2-story residential building”
- Alteration, filed Nov 24, 2021, estimated cost $345K, described as “Installation of sprinkler and standpipe system for entire building in conjunction with new building application # 510115876. No change in use, egress or occupacy.”
- Alteration, filed Oct 22, 2021, estimated cost $272K, described as “Installation of mechanical system for entire building in conjunction with new building application # 510115876. No change in use, egress or occupancy.”
- Alteration, filed Oct 22, 2021, estimated cost $420K, described as “Installation of plumbing system for entire building in conjunction with new building application # 510115876. No change in use, egress or occupancy.”
Property taxes
- Assessment
- $667,800
- 2026–27 tax
- $22,875
- Market value (city estimate)
- $1,484,000
- Taxable value
- $183,896
- Assessed land
- $667,800
Zoning
R3-2: floor area ratio 0.61 built, 0.75 allowed by base zoning.
Flood zone
Current FEMA flood map: zone X, minimal flood hazard.
Recent sales
- Jul 22, 2016: $1,900,000
Open-market sales since 2016, from the Department of Finance’s sales files.
Board and land use applications
- 1239 Forest Hill Road (City Planning 2025R0248): Certification, Completed, filed Mar 6, 2025, decided May 30, 2025. A private application requesting a Chair Certification per 105-41 that no authorization is required to facilitate the completion of the 2021 CPC (N210247ZCR) approval and the addition of a contiguous lot (Lot 44) for the development of…
- 1239 Forest Hill Road Residential (City Planning 2020R0136): Certification, Completed, filed Jan 12, 2021, decided Apr 19, 2021. This is a private application by Jay Goldstein requesting a certification ZR 105-41 to facilitate a new building development at 1239 Forest Hill Road in New Springville neighborhood, Community Board #2, Staten Island.
In the news
Permits Filed for 1239 Forest Hill Road in New Springville, Staten Island, New York YIMBY, Mar 31, 2021.