1235 Bay Street, Staten Island
Single family with store · built c. 1925 · Block 2831, Lot 13.
Building permits
- Alteration, filed Nov 17, 2025, estimated cost $95K, described as “Application filed to remove all interior work, furniture, appliances and finishes in existing commercial space. Plumbing application to be filed separately.”
Property taxes
- Assessment
- $46,020
- 2026–27 tax
- $4,431
- Market value (city estimate)
- $767,000
- Taxable value
- $22,328
- Assessed land
- $7,320
- Assessed improvements
- $38,700
Zoning
R4A: floor area ratio 1.01 built, above the 1.00 base zoning allows, which bonuses, transfers or older rules can permit.
Flood zone
Current FEMA flood map: zone X, minimal flood hazard.
Recent sales
- Feb 25, 2026: $675,000, 2,016 sq ft ($335 per sq ft)
Open-market sales since 2016, from the Department of Finance’s sales files.